The adviser as organizational narrator: Discursive productions in the promotion of change

Auteurs-es

  • Mariana Altopiedi Universidad de Sevilla

Mots-clés :

educational assessment, organizational change, narrative inquiry, institutional analysis.

Résumé

Probably, change has been one of the most discussed questions in educational field during last years. Administrations have tried to modify in different ways –and without much success, generally speaking- almost every dimension of educational system. Simultaneously, scholars have studied processes of change searching interpretations about them. Those efforts are probably sustained by the conception of change like something inherently positive for educational institutions. Consequently, the role of an educational assessor has been defined as a promoter of change in organizations. The way of doing that, according prescriptive models of change has been the ‘application’ of formalized strategies, almost like recipes. The dissonance between the results of this kind of intervention and the searched products has questioned organizational capacity of change, while the inherent value of organizational change and the opportunity of the strategies adopted to promote it have stayed unquestioned. This article is based on research findings derived from a study which employed a combination of quantitative and narrative approaches. Along the paper, we justify the convenience of adopting an interpretative point of view in the educational assessment and we suggest that promoting real changes in organizations requires a previous understanding of them. We also recommend the construction of organizational texts as a way of exposing a positive image of change that allows its development.

Références

Ainsworth, Susan (2001) Discourse Analysis as Social Construction: Towards Greater Integration of Approaches and Methods. Consultado el 20-08-05 en

http://www.mngt.waikato.ac.nz/research/ejrot/cmsconference/2001/Papers/Cons tructionKnowledge/Ainsworth.pdf

Angus, Lynne, LEVITT, Heidi y HARDTKE, Karen (1999) The Narrative process Coding System: Research Applications and Implications for Psychotherapy Practice. Journal of Clinical Psychology. 55(10) 1255- 1270.

BaldridgE, J. Victor y Deal, Terrence (1998) Shaping School Culture. San Francisco: JaseyBass Inc. Publishers.

Barbulescu, Roxana (2004) Rhetoric of change and defiant Resistance: responding to Environmental Shifts. Actas del 20º Coloquio de EGOS, Ljubljana, 1-3 de julio de 2004.

Boje, David (2002) Narrative Methods for Organizational & Communication Research. Londres: Sage Publications.

Bolin, María, Bergquiet, Magnus y Ljungberg, Jan (2004) Driving Change with Narratives. Actas del 20º Coloquio de EGOS, Ljubljana, 1-3 de julio de 2004.

Bolívar, Antonio (2004) Identidad organizativa y narrativa. Actas del 8º Congreso Interuniversitario de Organización de Instituciones Educativas. Sevilla, 10- 12 de noviembre de 2004.

Bruner, Jerome (1987) Realidad mental y mundos posibles. Barcelona. Gedisa Editorial.

Bruner, Jerome (2000) Actos de Significado. Más allá de la revolución Cognitiva. Madrid. Alianza Editorial.

Castoriadis, Cornelius (1975) L´institution imaginaire de la société. Paris: Éditions du Seuil. Clandinin, Jean y Conelly, Michael (2000) Narrative Inquiry. Experience and Story in Qualitative Research. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.

Coronel, José Manuel (2004) La organización como texto y las políticas de representación en la investigación sobre instituciones educativas. Actas del 8º Congreso Interuniversitario de Organización de Instituciones Educativas. Sevilla, 10- 12 de noviembre de 2004.

Cortazzi, Martin (1993) Narrative Analysis. Londres: the Falmer Press.

Cunliffe, Ann, Luhman, John y Boje, David (2004) Narrative Temporality: Implications for

Organizational Research. Organization Studies. 25(2) 261- 286.

Czarniawska, Barbara (2004) Narratives in Social Science Research. Londres: Sage Publications.

Derrida, Jacques (1999) La desconstrucción en las fronteras de la filosofía. Barcelona: Paidós- UAB.

Day, Christopher y Bakioglu, Aysen (1996) Development and Disenchantment in the Professional Lives of Headteachers. En: Hargreaves, A. y Goodson, I. (eds.) Teachers’ professional Lives. Londres: The Falmer Press.

Dimitrova, Dimitrina (1994) Trabajo, compromiso y alienación. Revista de Investigación en Ciencias Sociales. 140 239- 250.

Etzioni, Amitai (1975) Organizaciones modernas. Buenos Aires: Uteha.

Fernández, Lidia (1994) Instituciones educativas. Dinámicas institucionales en situaciones críticas. Buenos Aires: Paidós.

Foucault, Michel (1995) Historia de la sexualidad. Tomo 1: La voluntad de saber. Buenos Aires: Siglo Veintiuno.

Foucault, Michel (1988) Niezstche, la genealogía, la historia. Valencia: Pre-textos.

Gold, Barry (1999) Punctuted Legitimacy: A Theory of educational Change. Teachers College Record, 101(2) 192- 219.

Hardy, Cynthia (2004) Scaling Up and Bearing Down in Discourse Analysis: Questions Regarding Textual Agencies and their Contexts. Organization 11(3) 415- 426.

Hardy, Cynthia, Lawrence, Thomas y Grant, David (2005) Discourse and collaboration: the role of conversations and collective identity. Academy of Management Review 30(1) 58- 77.

Kirk, Phillip (2004) System Leadership Development. Actas del 20º Coloquio de EGOS, Ljubljana, 1-3 de julio de 2004.

Juuti, Pauli (1998) Managing change and learning in the system. Revista Española de Orientación y Psicopedagogía, 16, 2º Semestre, 181- 194.

Lavié, José Manuel (2000) Algunos referentes para repensar la formación docente. En: De Vicente, P. y Fernández, M. (coords.). Formación para la función docente: El acceso a la función pública en Andalucía. Granada: Grupo Editorial Universitario.

Levin, Benjamin (1993) School Response to Changing Environment. Journal of Educational Administration, 31(2) 4- 21.

Laïdi, Zaki (1997) Un mundo sin sentido. México: Fondo de Cultura Económica.

López Yáñez, Julián (2002) Hacia una nueva Teoría de los Sistemas Organizativos. En Gairín, J. y Darder, J.P. (coords.) Organización y gestión de centros educativos. Barcelona: Praxis.

Lueger, Manfred, Sandner, Kart, Meyer, Renate y Hammerschmidt, Gerhard (2005) Contextualizing influences Activities: An Objective Hermeneutical Approach. Organization Studies 26(8) 1145- 1168.

Mangham, Ian (2005) The Drama of Organizational Life. Organization Studies, 26(6) 941-958.

Mendel, Gérard (1972) Sociopsicoanálisis institucional. Buenos Aires: Amorrortu.

Mendel, Gérard (1994) La sociedad no es una familia. Buenos Aires: Paidós.

Mendel, Gérard (1996) Sociopsicoanálisis y educación. Buenos Aires: Ediciones Novedades educativas- Facultad de Filosofía y Letras- UBA.

Nicastro, Sandra (1997) La historia institucional y el director en la escuela. Versiones y relatos. Buenos Aires: Paidós.

Phillips, Nelson, Lawrence, Thomas y Hardy, Cynthia (2004) Discourse and institutions. Academy of Management Review 29(4) 635- 652.

Riessman, Catherine (2002) Narrative Analysis. En: Huberman, a. y Miles, M. (Eds.) The Qualitative Research’s Companion. Thousand Oaks: Sage Publications. Recuperado de http://www2.bc.edu/~riessman/pdf/Narrative%20Analysis.pdf [Consulta 25-08-05].

Riessman, Catherine (2004) Narrative Analysis. En: Lewis-Beck, M., Bryman, A. y Futing Liao, T. (Eds.) Encyclopaedia of Social Science Research Methods. London UK and Newbury Park CA: Sage Publications. Consultado el 25- 08- 2005 en el World Wide Web http://www2.bc.edu/~riessman/pdf/Narrative.pdf

Rodríguez, Mª Mar (2000). The representations of educational change. Revista Electrónica de Investigación Educativa, 2(2). Recuperado de http://redie.ens.uabc.mx/vol2no2/contenidoromero.html

Stoll, Louise y Fink, Dean (1998) Educational Change: Easier Said than Done. En: Hargreaves, A. y otros (Eds.). International Handbook of Educational Change. Dordrecht: Kluwer Academic Publishers.

Taylor, James y Robichaud, Daniel (2004) Finding the Organization in the Communication: Discourse as Action and Sensemaking. Organization 11(3) 395- 413.

Wortham, Stanton (2001) Narratives in Action. A Strategy for Research and Analysis. Nueva York: Teachers College Press.

Téléchargements

Publié-e

2008-04-01